April 17, 2024
History of RE Returns vs. Stock Market—Which Is More Stable and Why?

Are you considering diversifying your portfolio but aren't sure where to start? 

You may already have investments, a property in another city, or you’re into trading stocks. Now, you crave financial stability, a way to grow your wealth steadily over time. But with so many options, where do you begin?

Two titans dominate the investment landscape: real estate and the stock market. Both offer the potential for significant returns, but which one offers more stability?

Let's delve into historical data for each asset class. Uncover the inherent risks involved. Ultimately, it will help you make an informed decision about where to park your hard-earned cash.

Real Estate vs. Stocks: The Historical Performance

Historical data speaks volumes about investment returns. It paints a compelling picture of real estate returns being more stable than stocks.

Real estate has consistently delivered positive and predictable returns over the long term (think decades, not days). According to a study by Fidelity Investments, real estate has yielded an average annual return of around 8.9% since 1978.  That's compared to the stock market's historical average of roughly 10% over the same period. But with a crucial caveat: volatility.

Over the past 50 years, the average annual return for the S&P 500 (a widely followed stock market index) has been around 10.7%. Not bad, right? But the real story lies in the volatility. 

While offering potentially higher returns, the stock market is notorious for its dramatic swings. The 2008 financial crisis serves as a stark reminder. The most recent was the 34% plunge in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

While real estate values did experience a correction, the decline was far less severe and much quicker to recover. It has demonstrated a much more stable performance. 

Even during periods of economic uncertainty, real estate investments have tended to hold their value much better than stocks.  In many markets in 2008, Real estate only shortly dipped in value before recovering. 

Here is a chart from FRED  that shows even though prices fell significantly in 2008 - 2009; they rebounded quite quickly. 

Comparative Analysis: Risk Factors of Real Estate vs. Stocks

Risk is an inevitable part of investing. However, the nature of risk differs between real estate and stocks. These risks affect the return on your investments, which is why you should be aware of what you may be facing.

  1. Market Volatility: The stock market is a fickle industry. It’s susceptible to external factors like economic downturns, interest rate fluctuations, and even global events. A bad day on Wall Street can translate to significant losses in your portfolio. On the other hand, real estate offers a tangible asset—a physical property with intrinsic value. While market fluctuations can impact property values, these corrections are more gradual and localized, offering more time to weather the storm.

  1. Liquidity: Need to access your cash quickly? Stocks offer a high degree of liquidity. You can sell your shares on the stock exchange relatively easily (market conditions permitting). Real estate, however, is a less liquid asset. Selling a property takes time, and you're at the mercy of market forces. However, with a well-managed rental property, like those under HomeRoom’s listing, you can generate a steady income stream, providing a constant cash flow that stocks simply cannot match.

  1. Management: Owning stocks requires minimal day-to-day management. However, you're essentially putting the fate of your investment in the hands of the companies you choose. Real estate demands more active involvement, whether managing tenants or hiring a property manager. While this adds some responsibility, it also empowers you to exert greater control over your investment and maximize its returns.

Beyond the Numbers: Why Real Estate Wins the Stability Battle

The historical data and risk analysis paint a clear picture. Real estate offers a compelling combination of stable, long-term growth with a degree of control that stocks simply can't replicate. 

But the benefits extend far beyond mere numbers. Here are some additional factors you should consider:

  1. Tangible asset: Unlike a stock certificate, a piece of real estate is a physical asset you can see, touch, and even use (think co-living rentals!). This tangibility provides a sense of security and stability that a digital representation on a screen cannot.

  1. Leverage: Real estate investments allow you to leverage your capital through mortgages, enabling you to control a much larger asset than you could with the same amount of cash. You don’t have this kind of leverage when you opt to invest in stocks.

  1. Inflation Hedge: Over time, inflation erodes the purchasing power of your currency. Real estate, however, has historically proven to be a strong hedge against inflation. As the cost of living rises, so does the value of your property, protecting your wealth over the long term.

  1. Tax Benefits: Real estate investments offer many tax advantages, including deducting mortgage interest, property taxes, and depreciation expenses. None of these tax benefits apply to stocks.

  1. Passive Income Potential: Renting out your property creates a passive income stream. It provides a steady flow of cash that can supplement your salary or pay down debt. Essentially, renting out your property allows you to breathe more easily financially.

Choose HomeRoom as Your Real Estate Investment Partner

Have you finally decided to invest in real estate? If so, your next step is finding a good partner for investing.

At HomeRoom, we understand the power of real estate investment. However, we also recognize the challenges associated with property management. That's why we offer a unique platform that confidently empowers you to invest in real estate.

What’s more? We offer a co-living model that offers more benefits for real estate investors like you. This unique angle on real estate market can increase your annual investment returns.

Here's how we can help you achieve your real estate investment goals through co-living:

  • Streamlined Management: Our user-friendly app connects you with qualified renters, automates rent collection, and facilitates seamless communication, freeing you from the day-to-day hassles of property management.
  • Data-Driven Decisions: We equip you with powerful data analytics to make informed investment decisions. Identify high-performing rental markets, understand rental trends, and optimize your pricing strategy.
  • Real Estate Experts: Our experts are with you every step of the way. This way, you can have all the support you need to maximize your investment.

Leverage our expertise on real estate, co-living, and industry insights to maximize your returns. Don't wait any longer—take the first step toward securing your financial future through real estate investment.

Book A Consultation Call

Tags
Real Estate
Investing
Investment
Share